National Review Online interview.
Burt Solomon was featured on CSPAN’s Washington Journal
“This book marks Mr. Solomon's final transition from being one of
the city's best political journalists (for the National Journal) to becoming a
serious political historian…Mr. Solomon has produced a gripping tale of how
Roosevelt misjudged and mishandled the two men who denied him his remedy.”
—James Srodes, Washington Times. Read
full review.
“While many readers know how FDR's effort turned out, Solomon tells the tale the way
a good sportswriter would describe an exciting baseball game…. his tale is popular
history at its finest and provides many lessons about the dangers of presidential
arrogance.” —Claude R. Marx, Boston Globe. Read full review.
“Burt Solomon tells the remarkable story of the "Court packing" battle, and in the
telling, manages to illuminate some of the great themes of American history. Even
more remarkable, the book makes a fascinating case that the Court's flexibility and
willingness to overrule precedent, rather than making it seem feckless and fickle,
was the source of the Court's greatest strength…This book recounts the epic battle
over the legislation, and the important constitutional issues that were at stake, in
lively and compelling prose. Solomon's descriptions of the many players in the drama
are vivid and entertaining.”—Fabio Bertoni, New York Law Journal.
"[A] compelling and painstakingly researched study...Solomon eloquently reveals how
[FDR's] proposal-hotly debated in Congress and characterized as a direct challenge
to the fundamental principles of the Founders-eventually resulted in a stunning and
humiliating defeat for FDR, sharply dividing members of his own party in the
process."—Publishers Weekly
"In the mold of Anthony Lewis,
National Journal correspondent Solomon conveys the excitement and
significance of a core battle over the U.S. Constitution...he neatly captures the
political dynamic of interacting personalities…An engrossing story that hints at the
fragility as much as the triumph of democracy."—Kirkus Reviews
"Probably FDR’s most consequential political miscue as president—his proposal in
1937 to increase the membership of the Supreme Court—is the topic of journalist
Solomon’s lively historical narrative. Bringing forth the important political
players, Solomon highlights FDR and his conservative antagonists on the Court, who
had invalidated many New Deal programs. Professing to lighten their labors with his
proposal, FDR dissembled about his true aim of appointing new liberal justices,
which even stout New Dealers sensed as a dangerous presidential power-grab: a key
Democratic congressman said, "Boys, here’s where I cash in my chips." That, a
refutation of the overwork thesis by Chief Justice Charles Evans Hughes, and an
impassioned defense of the Supreme Court’s independence by Montana senator Burton
Wheeler defeated the plan. Parallel to recounting the public politics, Solomon
dramatizes the Court’s internal politics in response to the institutional threat it
felt, including—most memorably for historical lore—"a switch in time saved nine,"
pro–New Deal votes by hitherto anti–New Dealer Justice Owen Roberts. A fluid
portrayal of the court-packing episode that will appeal to history
buffs."—Gilbert Taylor, Booklist